Atheists:What are your thoughts about this Islamic Fatwa?

I come only upon this unbelievable fatwa.I a Moslem, I and i, however, you don\'t believe it.

The Fatwa: Ezzat Attiya: ErwachsenerErwachsener, that nurses in the job,

ImIm May 2007 surprised Ezzat Attiya for itself how undressed men and women could work together in the same office when Islam prohibits men and women, that are not married or are told, in order to be together alone. His/its answer: leave him/it F she/itÜNF TIME suckle. JaJa, that is right, an adult woman, that an adult männlichen coworker nurses, all the sexual tension will defuse in the office. See, the female worker now becomes the foster mother of the mis of ännlichen worker, and they can be together alone anytime. Attiya\'s decision was mocked intergalactic and also sentenced fast on the homefront. He/it became später from his/its work, that is denounced in Arabic newspapers, excluded and published a hasty retraction, that said, that it was a "bad interpretation of a particular case."

from Danny

Best answer chosen by voters

I guess that similarly almost all of the Ajam Muslim, you are unsuspecting from the fact that this fatwa is based on the Sahih Hadiths, the an incident quotes, where of Mohammad itself this ordained.

Sahih Muslim books 8, you count 3425:
\'A\'isha reported, Allah is pleased with her/it, that this Salim, the relieved slave of Abu Hadhaifa, with him/it and his/its family lived in her/its/their house. You/they, i. e. the daughter came to Allah\'s apostle (pbuh) from Suhail and said: SalimSalim attained, Pubertät, as men attain, and he/it understands, what they understand, and he/it enters our house freely, however, I perceive that something, nettles, in the heart of Abu Hudhaifa, on what Allah Apostle (pbuh) told her,: drinks you him/it, and you would become unlawful for him/it, and, the nettles, Abu Hudhaifa becomes feel which in his/its heart. She/it came theück and said: DeshalbDeshalb suckled him/it I, and that something, was there, in the heart of Abu Hudhaifa vanished.

The isnad [chain of the narrators] vomvom Sahih Bukhari, the Sirat Rasool\'illah, is the Sunans and so on too long in order to multiply here but, silence assured that everything is because of this of the command of Mohammad, itself.

FatwasFatwas of the Shari\'a is based on the Qur\'an and the Sahih Hadiths. You/they aren\'t spent only without right basis.

. 50 percent 2 voices saves to it! ! RSS

Other Answers (8)

from SH regardless of religion, we are all people. Nobody claims to be perfect although a religion is. People mißverstehen, and people do mistakes. This happens if they are not sufficiently knowledgeable. WennWenn you at the end sees, the fatwa became to theückgenommen, and he/it was punished, because of \'bad interpretation\'. which says, you kit only simply exports a fatwa önnen\'t, if it is unfair, people will contravene him/it, and jurispudence discusses to use the rules of the book.

from Maurog III, It is true, but. If you lächerliche limitations have, people invent workarounds ridiculous. Why wouldnwird \'t-Männern and women allows to work together? 25 percent 1 voices

from Mackey, that It makes for me in an office, filled itself with Muslim women.

through * Ajidamoon * Ojibwe-Prinzessin near the top of my list of most ridiculous matters heard per.

through caustic zebra what said Maurog,: manages you crazy rules, and people will jump through crazy tires in order to avoid her/it/them.

mango mushy through love is not It important.
All religions are angry.

through stupidity, it should be painful that I have a better question.Are, that remained behind you?

my avatar is I lol 25 percent 1 voices through it in 3